In this article
- What happens to old unpaid claims when you switch billing companies
- The five claim categories to separate before you switch
- Choosing the cutoff date: date of service, submission date, or payment date
- Timely filing and appeal deadlines during a transition
- How to triage by deadline
- The data export: what to request from the old company
- Reconciling the opening A/R balance
- Who works legacy claims: three arrangements
- Option 1: the old company works its claims for a run-off period
- Option 2: the new company takes everything at the cutoff
- Option 3: a split by category
- What recovery work on old unpaid claims involves
- Payments that arrive at the old company after the switch
- A week-by-week transition plan
- What goes wrong in a billing transition and how to prevent it
- How to measure whether the transition is working
- What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
- Next steps: size the legacy A/R before you switch
Decide the cutoff rule in writing before notice is given. Export a claim-level A/R report and reconcile it to a signed opening balance. Assign every open claim to a named owner. Review unbilled charges and claims near a filing deadline first. Expect some payments to keep arriving at the old company, and plan for how you will find and match them.
What happens to old unpaid claims when you switch billing companies
A claim is a record held in several places at once: your practice management system, the old company’s system or workflow, the clearinghouse, and the payer. Changing vendors changes who works the claim. It does not change the claim’s status at the payer, the payer’s deadlines, or the payment address on file.
In practice, four things happen at the moment of change:
- Claims in process continue. A claim submitted last week will be adjudicated on the payer’s timeline whatever you decide.
- Remittances keep arriving. Payment may still be directed to the old company’s account, lockbox, or clearinghouse enrollment.
- Follow-up stops unless reassigned. If nobody is named, aging claims sit idle.
- Unbilled charges stall. Charges captured in the old workflow but not yet submitted can slip past a filing deadline.
The core question is therefore not “what happens to old claims” but “who works each category of claim after the cutoff, and how do we know?” The categories are covered below.
The five claim categories to separate before you switch
Treat the open ledger as five groups. Each has a different risk and often a different owner.
| Category | Description | Main risk | Typical owner after cutoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Unbilled charges | Services rendered, charge entered or captured, claim not yet submitted | Missing a filing deadline | New company, with a priority review |
| 2. Submitted, no response | Claims sent, not yet adjudicated | Lost claims, no acknowledgment | Either, by written agreement |
| 3. Rejected | Failed front-end edits, never processed | Silent expiry while uncorrected | New company |
| 4. Denied or underpaid | Processed with a denial or partial payment | Appeal window lapsing, abandoned balances | Depends on contract; often the largest dispute |
| 5. Patient balances | Balance after insurance | Statements not sent, mixed messages to patients | New company or practice |
The distinction between categories 3 and 4 is not cosmetic. A rejected claim is corrected and sent again. A denied claim may need a corrected claim, a reconsideration request, or a formal appeal, with different deadlines. The article on claim rejection versus denial explains how to tell them apart on a remittance or clearinghouse report.
Choosing the cutoff date: date of service, submission date, or payment date
The cutoff rule decides which company is responsible for, and paid on, each claim. There are three common versions, and they produce very different results.
| Cutoff rule | How it works | Advantage | Disadvantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Date of service | Services before the date belong to the old company, after to the new one | Clean line, matches clinical calendar | Old company may stop work on claims for earlier dates that are still open |
| Submission date | Claims already submitted stay with the old company, unsubmitted go to the new one | Easy to audit from clearinghouse files | Leaves the old company with follow-up it may not want to do after termination |
| Payment date | Fees follow when money is received | Simple for fee calculation | Pays the old company for work after it left, or the new company for work it did not do |
The most common practical blend is this: the old company continues to work claims it submitted for a defined run-off period, the new company takes all unsubmitted charges and all services after the start date, and anything still unresolved at the end of the run-off period moves to the new company under agreed terms. Whatever you choose, write the rule into both contracts in the same words. Mismatched definitions are where the same payment gets claimed twice, or by no one.
Review the old agreement for tail provisions: fees on collections after termination, minimum notice periods, and obligations to continue follow-up. The guide to medical billing pricing models describes how percentage bases and tail periods work, which is often the starting point for negotiating a clean cutoff.
Timely filing and appeal deadlines during a transition
Payers set limits on how long you have to submit a claim and how long you have to appeal a decision. Those limits are set by the payer and the contract, and they vary. Medicare fee-for-service has a general rule in federal regulation that a claim must be filed within one calendar year after the date of service, with limited exceptions. Commercial plans and Medicaid programs each have their own windows, which may be shorter or longer and may differ for corrected claims and appeals. Never assume one number applies to every payer. Check each payer’s current policy and your contract.
A transition raises timely filing risk for three reasons:
- Charge lag. Charges captured in the last weeks of the old relationship may not be entered if the old company stops working.
- Handoff gaps. Claims that were rejected before the handoff may never have been corrected.
- Proof of timely filing. When a claim is denied for filing limits, you may need proof of original submission, such as a clearinghouse acceptance report or payer acknowledgment. If the old company holds those records, you need them exported.
How to triage by deadline
- Pull every claim with no payment, any denial, and any unbilled charge.
- For each payer, record the filing limit and appeal limit from the contract or provider manual.
- Compute the days remaining on each claim from the date of service, or from the denial date for appeals.
- Sort ascending by days remaining and assign the shortest list first.
- Keep acceptance reports and payer acknowledgments with each claim as proof of timely filing.
Hypothetical example. The numbers here are round illustrations. A practice with 600 open claims discovers that 40 have a date of service far enough back that the filing limit of one of its payers may be near. The new company works those 40 first, before doing anything to the other 560. It gathers proof of original submission for any that were filed previously, submits unbilled charges at once, and requests reconsideration where a denial for filing is clearly attributable to a payer error. The remaining claims are worked by age. Nobody can promise that all 40 will pay, because payer decisions govern the result, but the first week was spent on the claims that could be lost entirely.
The data export: what to request from the old company
Do not rely on a summary. Ask for claim-level data in a usable format such as spreadsheet or CSV files, along with the supporting documents. Write the request as a list with a date.
| Item | What it should contain | Why you need it |
|---|---|---|
| Open A/R detail | Claim ID, patient account number, date of service, payer, billed amount, payments, adjustments, balance, status | Baseline for every later report |
| Unbilled charges | Date of service, codes, provider, reason not billed | Filing deadline control |
| Rejections and denials | Reason codes, remark codes, dates, actions taken | Correct and appeal without repeating work |
| Payment history | Posted payments and remittance files (835) for a defined lookback period | Resolve disputes about what was paid |
| Clearinghouse reports | Acceptance reports, payer acknowledgments | Proof of timely filing |
| Appeal history | Dates, letters, outcomes, reference numbers | Avoid duplicate appeals and track deadlines |
| Authorization records | Authorization numbers, dates, units | Support claims denied for missing authorization |
| Payer correspondence and call notes | Who said what and when | Continuity on escalated accounts |
| Fee schedules and payer setup | Contracted rates, payer IDs, enrollment status | Setup of the new workflow |
| Patient statements and balances | Last statement date and balance | Avoid duplicate or conflicting statements |
Protected health information is involved in this exchange. Make sure a business associate agreement is in place with the new company before data moves, and that the old agreement’s terms for return of information are followed. HHS sample business associate provisions describe return or destruction of information at termination, so check that your existing contract has equivalent language.
Reconciling the opening A/R balance
The opening balance is the one number both companies, and you, must agree on. Without it, later reports cannot be trusted.
- Take a ledger snapshot from your practice management system as of the cutoff date.
- Compare to the old company’s A/R report. Differences are common and usually come from payments in transit, unposted remittances, and adjustments entered on different dates.
- Break differences into categories: timing, posting error, duplicate, missing claim, and disputed adjustment.
- Resolve or document each item. Large unexplained gaps should be investigated before the handoff, not after.
- Sign off. The practice, old company, and new company should accept a final opening A/R report by payer and age bucket.
Use the aging buckets from your reports: current, 31 to 60, 61 to 90, 91 to 120, and over 120 days. The guide on how to reduce A/R over 90 days explains what to do with the older buckets once the baseline is set.
Who works legacy claims: three arrangements
Option 1: the old company works its claims for a run-off period
The old company continues to follow up on claims it submitted for a defined period after termination, commonly with a fee on collections during that time. This keeps knowledge with the people who know the history. The risk is low attention. A departing vendor has little incentive to chase hard denials. Set a run-off end date, reporting during the period, and a clear transfer of unresolved items at the end.
Option 2: the new company takes everything at the cutoff
All open claims move to the new company on the start date. This gives one accountable owner and a simple handoff, but it depends on a complete data export and may trigger tail fees under the old contract. It also means the new company must learn the history from records, not from the people who did the work.
Option 3: a split by category
The old company keeps claims in process with the payer, and the new company takes unbilled charges, rejections, and denials. This divides the work by status, which can be efficient when the old company is cooperative. It needs a precise rule for what counts as in process, or claims will fall between the two.
The right option depends on your old contract, the quality of the data, and the old company’s cooperation. In all three, put the allocation in writing and name an owner for every claim.
What recovery work on old unpaid claims involves
Old claims are not just aged claims. Each one is a puzzle with a likely reason it stalled. Typical steps for the new company are:
- Verify claim status with the payer through the portal, clearinghouse, or phone, and record the answer.
- Classify each unpaid claim: never received, rejected, denied, partially paid, pending, or paid but not posted.
- Look for payments hidden in the system. Remittances sent to the old company or posted to the wrong account can make a paid claim look open.
- Correct and resubmit where the cause is an error: wrong payer ID, eligibility, missing modifier, missing information. Corrected claims often need specific frequency codes and original claim references, which differ by payer.
- Appeal where the denial is wrong and the deadline is open. Appeals need supporting documents such as records, authorization proof, and a clear explanation.
- Write off or adjust only after review, when the claim cannot be recovered because of timely filing, a contractual limit, or a correct denial. Document the reason.
The Mednex pages on accounts receivable recovery and denial management describe this type of work in detail. For revenue lost when charges never reach a claim at all, see the overview of revenue leakage in healthcare.
Payments that arrive at the old company after the switch
This is the single most common surprise. Payers pay to the address and account on file. Until enrollment and payment details are updated, some remittances will continue to go to the old company.
- Electronic funds transfer and ERA enrollment. Update with each payer, and confirm that the old company’s enrollment is ended or redirected. Processing times differ by payer.
- Paper checks. Check payment addresses and lockbox arrangements.
- Clearinghouse mapping. If the new company uses a new clearinghouse, make sure remittance files go to the right recipient.
- Handling stray payments. Agree on a written process: the old company forwards payments or remittance data within a stated number of days, with the claim reference and the patient account number.
- Payment ownership. Payments belong to the practice. The contract should not allow the old company to retain funds beyond its agreed fee.
Plan to review posted payments against bank deposits weekly in the first two months. The article on payment posting in medical billing describes how remittance and deposit matching should work so you can recognize a gap quickly.
A week-by-week transition plan
| When | Action | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Before notice | Read the old contract for notice, tail fees, data return, and run-off terms. Pull A/R and denial reports. Identify payer filing limits. | Practice |
| Before notice | Sign a BAA with the new company. Agree the cutoff rule and legacy claim allocation in writing. | Practice, new company |
| Notice week | Send termination notice and a written data request list with a due date. | Practice |
| Weeks 1 to 2 | Receive exports. Review unbilled charges and claims near filing deadlines first. Set up system access and clearinghouse. | New company |
| Weeks 1 to 3 | Start payer updates: payment address, EFT, ERA, and provider data. Confirm enrollment of the billing arrangement where required. | New company, practice |
| Weeks 2 to 4 | Reconcile the opening A/R balance. Classify all open claims. Begin work on deadline-sorted list. | All |
| Weeks 3 to 6 | Run-off reporting from the old company. Match incoming payments weekly. | Old company, new company |
| End of run-off | Transfer unresolved claims. Confirm return or destruction of data under the BAA. | All |
| Months 2 to 3 | First full reporting cycle on clean claim rate, denial rate, days in A/R, and over-90 balance. Compare with the opening baseline. | New company, practice |
The actual calendar depends on payer enrollment timelines and the old company’s cooperation. Do not treat the table as a promise of a fixed duration.
What goes wrong in a billing transition and how to prevent it
| Problem | Cause | Prevention |
|---|---|---|
| Claims fall into a gap | No owner assigned to category 2 or 3 claims | Owner column in the A/R export; weekly review |
| Filing deadline missed | Unbilled charges not reviewed first | Triage by days remaining |
| Same claim worked twice | Both companies follow up after the cutoff | Single cutoff rule in both contracts |
| Payments lost | Remittances sent to old company or old clearinghouse | Payer updates, weekly deposit reconciliation |
| Fee dispute | Different cutoff definitions or tail terms | Written definitions; agree on stray payment procedure |
| Patient confusion | Statements from both companies | Agree who sends statements and from what date |
| Missing history | Export lacks notes, appeals, authorization data | Itemized export request and sign-off |
| Data retained by old company | No return or destruction terms | BAA and contract terms; written confirmation |
How to measure whether the transition is working
Pick a baseline from the opening A/R report and compare each month. Useful measures:
- A/R by age bucket and payer versus opening, with new charges separated from legacy claims.
- Legacy claim resolution: the count and dollar amount of legacy claims paid, adjusted, appealed, or written off, with reasons.
- Unbilled charge lag: days between date of service and claim submission.
- Clean claim rate and denial rate on claims submitted by the new company.
- Payments located after the switch: stray payments received by the old company and forwarded.
- Reconciliation gap: difference between posted payments and bank deposits.
Do not judge the new company on total collections in the first month. Cash is volatile during a changeover. Judge the process measures first.
What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
For a practice moving to Mednex, the team reviews the exported A/R, sorts claims by status and deadline, works rejections and denials through medical billing and accounts receivable recovery workflows, and reports on legacy claims separately from new billing. Mednex cannot guarantee that old claims will be paid, because payer decisions, filing limits, and the condition of the records control the result.
The practice terminates the old agreement in line with its terms, requests the data, signs the business associate agreement, authorizes payer changes, supplies provider and payer information, and confirms the cutoff rule. Specific onboarding steps and data access methods are confirmed in writing during the engagement.
Next steps: size the legacy A/R before you switch
You will plan the transition better if you know what is open. Start with an A/R aging report by payer and a denial report from the last two quarters. If you want a written look at your old unpaid claims, denial reasons, and charge capture gaps before you commit to a change, the free medical billing audit reviews a sample and returns a summary with a walkthrough call. Provide report exports only, and keep patient records out of the website form. For the evaluation side of the decision, read the list of questions to ask a medical billing company, or see the full Mednex blog for related guides.
This guide is educational. It is not legal, coding, compliance or clinical advice. Rules differ by payer, plan, state and contract, so confirm against the payer's current policy before acting.
Frequently asked questions
What happens to old unpaid claims when you switch billing companies?
They do not disappear, but they can fall through the gap if no one owns them. Before the change, decide in writing who works claims billed before the cutoff date: the old company for a defined period, the new company, or your own staff. Export the open A/R by payer and age, set the rules for payments that arrive after the cutoff, and track claims near filing or appeal limits. Without a plan, unpaid claims can age past a payer's deadline while each side assumes the other has them. Put the plan in an email both companies confirm, so there is a record of who agreed to what.
Who should work legacy A/R during a transition?
It depends on the contracts and the state of your accounts, so settle it before the switch. Options include the old company working claims for a set wind-down period, the new company taking over open claims from day one, or a split by age or payer. Whichever you choose, name an owner for each bucket, the fee that applies, and the report that shows progress. Check the old contract for tail provisions, which may give the old company a fee on payments received after termination. Keep your own staff in the loop, since they often know which payers and claims are the real problems.
How do I avoid missing timely filing deadlines when changing billing companies?
Build a deadline list before the cutoff. Export all unbilled and open claims with date of service, payer, and last action, then calculate each payer's filing and appeal window from the contract or current payer policy, because these vary and are not universal. Rank by time left, and work those first. Medicare Part B generally requires filing within 12 months of service, with limited exceptions, but commercial and Medicaid plans set their own limits. Confirm every window with the payer. Revisit the list weekly during the transition, because claims move between buckets as time passes.
What data should I get from my old billing company?
Request a claim-level A/R aging by payer, a list of unbilled charges, claims with denials or rejections and their reasons, remittance (ERA/835) history, patient ledger balances, payer enrollment and clearinghouse details, fee schedules, and any notes or appeal logs. Ask for an export in a usable format such as spreadsheet or CSV, and a statement of any payments in transit. Do this early, because access can end on the termination date, and protected health information must be returned or destroyed according to your agreement. Ask for a signed confirmation of what was exported, so any missing item can be traced.
What is a cutoff date and how should I set it?
A cutoff date is the date after which a company is no longer responsible for new charges and claims. Many practices use a date of service or a submission date. Choose it with both companies, state it in writing, and cover edge cases: charges entered but not yet billed, rejected claims, secondary claims, patient balances, and payments received after the date. A clean cutoff reduces disputes about who earned a fee and who should have worked a claim. Revisit the cutoff in writing if the switch date moves, since a shifted date changes who owns which claims.
Will payments on old claims go to the old company or the new one?
This depends on the contract and where the payments are routed. If payers send checks or electronic payments to a lockbox or account the old company controls, you need to change payment destinations and watch for payments that arrive late. Reconcile deposits against remittances so no payment is posted twice or lost. Decide in advance whether the old company can charge on payments received after termination, and keep a log of post-termination payments for both sides. Keep the deposit log for several months after the switch, because late payments are common.
Can a new billing company recover old unpaid claims?
A new company can review old A/R and work claims that are still within payer filing and appeal limits and have a realistic basis for payment, but it cannot guarantee recovery, because payers decide. Some claims will be uncollectible due to missed deadlines, patient responsibility, or payer policy. A review of the aging, denial history, and claim notes tells you which claims are worth working and in what order. Ask how the company prices old claim work and how it reports results. Ask what proof of a claim's history the company will need, such as remittances, notes, and prior appeal letters.
How do I reconcile reports between two companies?
Use bank deposits, remittances, and the A/R aging as the common source. At the cutoff, take a snapshot of open A/R from the old company and agree on it. Then track each claim as it moves: still open, paid, denied, written off, or transferred. Monthly, compare total payments in the new company's reports with deposits, and compare the opening balance plus new charges minus payments and adjustments with the closing A/R. Differences should be explained claim by claim. Hold a short monthly reconciliation meeting until the totals match, then move to a quarterly check.
What should I check in my contract before leaving a billing company?
Check the term and notice period, any early termination fee, tail provisions on payments after termination, data export and return obligations, the process for returning or destroying protected health information, and how access to your systems is removed. Ask counsel to read it, because language varies. Plan the notice date around your timely filing risk, and do not stop all follow-up work during the notice period. A clean exit usually requires both sides to follow the written steps. Send the notice in writing and keep proof of the date it was delivered.
How long does a billing company transition take?
There is no universal timeline. It depends on how many payers and providers you have, the condition of your data, how soon access and exports are provided, and the size of your open A/R. Ask the new company for a written plan with steps, owners, and what you must provide, and for a realistic estimate tied to your situation. Avoid plans that skip the cutoff, deadline list, or reconciliation, because shortcuts there are where claims get lost. Review progress against the plan at set points, and escalate early if a step slips.
