In this article
- How to use this list of questions
- Questions about scope: what the company will actually do
- Questions about specialty and payer experience
- Questions about reporting and performance measures
- Questions about HIPAA, the BAA, and data security
- Questions about system access and workflow
- Questions about contract terms, fees, and exit rights
- Questions about transition, onboarding, and old claims
- Questions about data ownership and leaving
- Questions about denials, escalation, and accountability
- Questions about staffing and references
- Scoring the answers: a worked example
- Warning signs during the evaluation
- What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
- Next steps: test the answers against your own claims
Ask for everything in writing. Test each answer against your own data, such as your A/R aging and denial report. Treat any promise of a specific collection result as a warning, because payers make the final payment decisions. Before you sign, confirm who owns the data, how you can leave, and what you will receive every month.
How to use this list of questions
Most practices interview billing companies the way they interview vendors: a demo, a price, a reference call. That order favors whoever presents best. A stronger method is to prepare your own evidence first, then ask questions that force the company to respond to it.
Before the first call, gather four items:
- An A/R aging report by payer for the most recent month end.
- A denial or remittance report for the last quarter, grouped by reason.
- Your payer list with the approximate share of visits for each.
- A list of your systems: practice management, EHR, clearinghouse, and any patient payment tools.
Do not send protected health information to a company that has not signed a business associate agreement. Summary reports with patient identifiers removed are enough for a first conversation. Score each answer from 0 to 2: zero for vague or evasive, one for reasonable but unwritten, two for specific and contractually committed. The total score is less important than the zeros.
Questions about scope: what the company will actually do
Scope disputes cause more unhappy billing relationships than rate disputes. A practice assumes denial work is included. The company assumes it is optional. Pin down each task.
- Which tasks do you perform from registration through patient statements? Strong answer: a written task list with the owner of each line. Weak answer: “we handle everything.”
- Do you verify eligibility and benefits before visits? Eligibility errors are a frequent source of denials, and catching them before the visit is cheaper than fixing them after.
- Who reviews coding and modifiers? Find out whether the company reviews codes entered by your providers or only keys what it receives, and whether certified coders are involved.
- How do you handle denials? Ask how denials are categorized, who decides whether to appeal, how corrected claims are tracked, and whether there is a minimum balance below which claims are not worked.
- How far do you pursue unpaid claims? Ask what follow-up cadence applies at 30, 60, 90, and 120 days, and what happens to claims past that.
- Do you handle prior authorization, credentialing, and enrollment? If not, ask who does. These are separate functions on which billing depends. See the Mednex pages on prior authorization services and medical credentialing services for what each involves.
- How do you handle patient balances? Statement frequency, payment plans, phone contact, and whether any patient collections activity is done in your name.
- Do you work all payers, including workers compensation, auto, and self-pay? Some companies exclude the payers with unusual rules.
- What is explicitly out of scope? A company that cannot answer this has probably not thought about its boundaries.
For a visual of the full chain of work, the guide to the medical billing process step by step is a useful baseline to hold each answer against.
Questions about specialty and payer experience
General billing skill does not guarantee specialty skill. A company that is strong in primary care may mishandle anesthesia time units, behavioral health telehealth rules, or dental coordination of benefits.
- How do you handle my specialty’s coding rules? Listen for specifics. For behavioral health, that includes time-based psychotherapy codes, documentation of session length, and telehealth modifiers and place of service rules. For dental, it includes CDT codes and the ADA claim form. For medical specialties, it includes CPT or HCPCS, ICD-10-CM, and modifier use.
- Which payers in my area cause the most denials, and what do you do about them? A thoughtful answer names categories (prior authorization, medical necessity edits, enrollment) rather than reciting a generic list.
- How do you stay current with payer policy changes? Look for a process: bulletin monitoring, a named owner, and a way policy updates reach the people who submit claims.
- Do you work with my EHR and clearinghouse? Ask for the connection method and who pays for it.
If you are in a specific specialty, compare what you hear with the details on the relevant Mednex specialty page, for example mental health billing services, dental billing services, or primary care billing services.
Questions about reporting and performance measures
You cannot manage what you cannot see. The best protection against a poor billing relationship is a reporting package that you can verify against your own bank deposits and payer portals.
- What reports do I receive, how often, and in what format? At minimum: A/R aging by payer and age bucket, charges and payments by period, denials by reason and payer, and claims submitted versus claims paid.
- How do you define clean claim rate, denial rate, and days in A/R? Definitions differ. Ask for the formula and the denominator, then write it into the contract. The guide to clean claim rate and days in A/R shows the common calculations.
- Can I see a sample report with the identifiers removed? A company that cannot produce one has probably not standardized its reporting.
- How do reports reconcile to deposits? Payments in the report should match remittances and bank activity. Ask how differences are investigated.
- How often do we meet to review results? A monthly review with action items is a reasonable minimum, though the right cadence depends on volume.
- Do I have direct access to the data? Read-only access to the billing system or portal is far better than monthly PDF files.
| Report | What it reveals | Red flag if missing |
|---|---|---|
| A/R aging by payer | Where unpaid money is stuck and how old it is | Company reports only totals |
| Denials by reason code and payer | Root causes and repeat patterns | Only counts of appeals filed |
| Charges, payments, adjustments | Reconciliation to your ledger and deposits | Payments shown without adjustments |
| Claims submitted and lag from date of service | Charge entry speed and timely filing risk | No visibility into submission lag |
| Rejection report | Front-end errors that block claims | Rejections handled but never reported |
| Patient balance aging | Patient collection health | Patient accounts combined with insurance |
Questions about HIPAA, the BAA, and data security
A billing company handles protected health information in nearly every task. Under HIPAA, a company that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits that information for a covered entity is a business associate and needs a written agreement before it starts. HHS publishes sample business associate agreement provisions that outline typical content, including permitted uses, safeguards, breach reporting, subcontractor flow-down, and return or destruction of information at termination.
- Will you sign a business associate agreement before we exchange any patient data? The answer should be an unqualified yes. Ask whether they use their own form or yours, and have counsel review either.
- Do you use subcontractors or offshore staff? The BAA should require subcontractors to follow the same restrictions. Ask where staff are located and what access they have.
- How is access controlled? Look for unique user logins, role-based access, multi-factor authentication, and removal of access when staff leave.
- How is data transmitted and stored? Ask about encryption in transit and at rest, and whether files are sent by email.
- What is your breach notification process? The agreement should specify how quickly the practice is told and what information is provided.
- Do you perform a security risk analysis and train staff? Ask for a description of the process. Be cautious of claims such as “fully compliant,” because compliance is an ongoing program, not a badge.
- What happens to our data when the contract ends? Ask for return or destruction terms and the timeline for each.
- Do you keep an audit trail of who accessed or changed accounts?
Evaluate using de-identified summary reports until a business associate agreement is signed. A reputable company will ask you to wait for the agreement before sending detailed records.
Questions about system access and workflow
The access model decides how much friction the relationship creates. It also decides who can see what, and whether you can leave without losing history.
- Do you work inside my EHR or practice management system, or in your own platform? If inside yours, you keep the ledger. If in theirs, ask how data stays synchronized with your system.
- Who owns the payer portal logins and clearinghouse account? Accounts should be in the practice’s name, with the company as an authorized user. This makes a later transition far easier.
- How do charges get to you, and how fast? Ask about charge capture turnaround. Delays in charge entry shorten the time left before a payer’s filing deadline.
- What do you need from my staff daily? Eligibility changes, authorization numbers, front-desk collections, and documentation queries should have an agreed path.
- How do documentation questions reach providers? Coding queries should be sent through a defined process and recorded.
- Who receives and deposits payments? Electronic remittance and deposits should be directed to an account the practice controls.
Questions about contract terms, fees, and exit rights
The best time to ask about leaving is before you join. For a longer treatment of how fees are built, read the guide to medical billing pricing models.
- What is the pricing model, and what is the base? Percentage of what, exactly? Ask whether front-desk collections and payments on pre-existing claims are included.
- What fees apply beyond the main rate? Setup, clearinghouse, statements, appeals, credentialing, and reports.
- What is the initial term, and how does renewal work? Ask about automatic renewal and the notice window.
- Can I terminate without cause? With how much notice, and with what charges?
- Do you charge fees after termination? If so, on which claims and for how long.
- What performance commitments are in the agreement? Reports on time, response to inquiries, and a remedy if they are missed.
- Who is liable for billing errors that lead to overpayments or recoupments? The practice remains responsible to payers, so ask how the company shares the work of correcting them.
- Can rates change during the term? Ask for notice requirements.
Questions about transition, onboarding, and old claims
Switching is where most of the risk sits. Claims in motion do not stop for a vendor change. Ask for a written transition plan.
- What does onboarding involve, in order, and what do you need from me? Expect a list: BAA, system access, payer and fee schedule data, enrollment status, open claims, A/R reports, and provider information.
- Who works claims submitted before the start date? This is the question that causes the most trouble. See what happens to old unpaid claims when you switch billing companies for the full process.
- What cutoff date applies for old and new claims? The date of service, the submission date, and the payment date lead to very different outcomes.
- How do you protect against timely filing problems during the changeover? Ask what the company checks for unbilled charges at the start.
- How do you reconcile the opening A/R balance? A signed-off opening balance is the baseline for every later report.
- What parallel period, if any, applies? Some practices run both vendors briefly. Ask whether this is supported and how overlap is avoided.
Questions about data ownership and leaving
- Who owns the billing data, claims history, and patient ledgers? The practice should.
- What format and timeline apply to data export? Ask for claim-level history, payments, adjustments, notes, and open A/R in a usable format, not only PDFs.
- Is there a fee to export?
- Will you keep working open claims for a defined period after termination?
- How do you confirm destruction of data you no longer need?
A practice that can leave cleanly negotiates from a stronger position and has less reason to fear a mistake in the selection.
Questions about denials, escalation, and accountability
Denials show how well a company works when the easy claims are gone. Probe these topics with the denial report you collected.
- Walk me through how you would categorize these denials. Use a real reason mix from your report. A strong answer groups by cause such as eligibility, authorization, coding, medical necessity, duplicates, coordination of benefits, and timely filing. The article on why medical claims are denied uses this same grouping.
- How do you separate rejections from denials? The distinction affects the fix and the appeal rights. See claim rejection versus denial.
- What is your appeal process, and who signs off? Some appeals need a provider letter or medical records.
- How do you feed denial patterns back to my front desk and providers? Prevention is where lasting savings come from.
- Who is my named contact, and what is the escalation path? Ask for the response expectation in writing and the next level if it fails.
- What happens when a payer changes a rule mid-year?
- How do you handle an audit request or records request from a payer? Ask who prepares records and how the practice is notified.
Questions about staffing and references
- Who will work my account, and is that person dedicated or shared? Continuity matters because payer-specific knowledge sits with people.
- What training and quality checks apply to staff? Ask how errors are found and corrected, and whether work is sampled.
- What happens when my account manager is out or leaves?
- Can I speak with a practice of similar size and specialty? Ask what they would do differently, how the first 90 days went, and whether reports matched their deposits.
- Why have clients left? A company that has never lost a client is either new or not telling you everything. A thoughtful answer about reasons is a good sign.
When you speak to references, ask questions that cannot be answered with praise: how long did reports take to become reliable, what was the worst surprise, how were disputes handled, and did the invoice match the proposal.
Scoring the answers: a worked example
Hypothetical example. A three-provider practice interviews two companies. The scores below are illustrations of the method, not real results.
| Topic | Company 1 | Company 2 | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Written scope with exclusions | 2 | 1 | Company 2 described services verbally only |
| Sample report with definitions | 2 | 0 | Company 2 could not define days in A/R |
| BAA before data exchange | 2 | 2 | Both agreed |
| Practice owns portal and clearinghouse accounts | 2 | 0 | Company 2 uses its own accounts |
| Old claims plan | 1 | 0 | Company 1 had a draft, Company 2 had none |
| Data export terms | 2 | 1 | Company 2 mentioned a fee but no format |
| Denial categorization using the practice’s report | 2 | 1 | Company 2 gave a generic answer |
Company 1 totals 13 of 14 and has no zeros. Company 2 totals 5 and has three zeros, each on an item that is hard to fix after signing. Even if Company 2 quoted a lower rate, the zeros on ownership of accounts and old claims would push the real cost higher. Use the same format with your own questions and weight the topics that matter most to you.
Warning signs during the evaluation
- Claims of a specific collection result or denial rate before reviewing your data.
- An unwillingness to put answers in writing.
- Pressure to sign quickly or a discount that expires.
- Payments flowing to an account you do not control.
- No named person responsible for your account.
- Reports that cannot be reconciled to deposits.
- Vague answers on security, subcontractors, or offshore access.
- No clear process for the first 90 days.
What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
Mednex handles the billing workflow it is engaged for, which can include eligibility verification, claim submission, payment posting, denial management, and A/R follow-up under its medical billing service. Reporting content and cadence, access method, and BAA terms are confirmed in writing at the start of an engagement. The practice provides accurate documentation and charge information, keeps ownership of its payer and clearinghouse accounts where possible, and makes policy decisions about write-offs and patient balances. Neither party controls payer decisions, so no billing company can promise a particular reimbursement result.
Next steps: test the answers against your own claims
The fastest way to see whether a company’s answers hold up is to compare them with your actual data. If you would like an independent view of your denial reasons, A/R aging, and charge capture gaps before you commit to any vendor, the free medical billing audit gives you a written findings summary and a walkthrough call, with no obligation. Share report exports only, and never send patient records through the website form. You can also read the comparison of outsourcing versus in-house billing if you are still deciding whether to outsource at all, or browse the Mednex blog for related guides.
This guide is educational. It is not legal, coding, compliance or clinical advice. Rules differ by payer, plan, state and contract, so confirm against the payer's current policy before acting.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most important questions to ask a medical billing company?
Start with scope, pricing, and reporting: what work is included, what the fee is based on, and what reports you receive and how often. Then ask about security and access: whether they sign a business associate agreement, how they access your EHR and payer portals, and who owns your data. Finally ask about contract terms, transition and exit. If the answers are vague or avoid specifics, that is itself useful information. Ask for each answer in writing so you can compare companies on the same basis. Bring the list to every vendor call so each company answers the same questions, and record who gave which answer.
Does a medical billing company need a business associate agreement?
Under HIPAA, a company that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits protected health information for a covered entity as part of billing is a business associate, and a written agreement is required before it starts. HHS publishes sample provisions that cover permitted uses, safeguards, breach reporting, subcontractors, and return or destruction of information at termination. Ask the company to sign yours or provide theirs for review, ask who their subcontractors are, and have counsel check the agreement. Never send patient records through a website form. If a company hesitates to sign an agreement, treat that as a reason to look elsewhere.
How should a billing company get access to my EHR and payer portals?
Ask for a written description of the access method and who will use it. Common approaches include user accounts in your practice management or EHR system, secure file exchange, and delegated access to payer portals and clearinghouse accounts. Prefer named user accounts with limited permissions over shared logins, and ask how access is removed when someone leaves or the contract ends. Confirm that the clearinghouse enrollment and payer accounts remain under your practice's control, so you keep access if you change vendors. Ask for a written description rather than a verbal one, and revisit it whenever staff or systems change.
What reports should a medical billing company provide?
At minimum, expect claim-level and summary reports on charges, claims submitted, payments, adjustments, denials, and A/R aging by payer. Ask for the written definition of each metric, such as clean claim rate, denial rate, and days in A/R, and for the report frequency. Ask whether you can see claim-level detail, not just totals, and whether you can export data in a usable format. Reports you cannot verify against your own bank deposits and remittances are of limited use. Request a sample report before signing, so you can judge whether the layout answers your own questions.
Who owns the data and claims if I leave a billing company?
Your practice should own its patient and billing data, claim history, remittances, and payer enrollments, and the contract should say so. Ask for the exit process in writing: how you get a full export, in what format, in what timeframe, whether there is a fee, and how the company handles protected health information after termination. Also ask who works claims in progress and how payments received after the end date are handled. Ask this before signing, because it is hard to negotiate at the end. Put the answer in the contract itself, not only in a sales email, so it still applies years from now.
How do I check references for a billing company?
Ask for references from practices of similar specialty, size, and payer mix, and ask the references specific questions: How was the transition? How are problems escalated? Do reports match deposits? How long did it take to resolve a payer issue? Also ask what they would change. Keep in mind a company chooses its references, so ask for a range and check public reviews carefully. Do not rely on unverified statistics a company quotes about its results, and ask how any figure was calculated. Weigh a reference's answers against your own situation, since a different specialty or payer mix changes the picture.
What contract terms should I watch for?
Watch the term length, auto-renewal, notice period, early termination fees, minimums, the fee base, tail provisions on payments after termination, data return, liability limits, and how disputes are resolved. Check whether the fee applies to payments on claims billed before the start date, and whether extra services such as credentialing or appeals cost more. Have someone who reviews your practice contracts read it. Do not accept verbal promises on matters the written agreement does not cover. Ask for redlines in writing, and compare two or three companies' terms side by side before you decide.
How long does it take to switch to a new billing company?
It depends on your systems, the number of payers, the state of your A/R, and how quickly records and access are shared, so any fixed timeline from a company is an estimate. A transition typically involves access setup, data and report exports, payer and clearinghouse changes, a cutoff date, and a plan for old claims. Ask the company to write the steps, the owner of each step, and what you need to provide. Review the article on old unpaid claims when switching billing companies before you set the cutoff. Use that written plan to compare vendors, since a vague plan often predicts a rough transition.
Does a billing company guarantee higher collections?
No company can honestly guarantee collections, because payers decide what they pay under their policies and your contracts. Be careful with guarantees and with promised percentages, speed, or rates that come with no explanation of how they are measured. A reputable company can describe its process, responsibilities, reporting, and how it handles denials and aged claims. Ask what it will do, how you will see it, and how it defines each number it reports. Ask for the reporting that would show whether the process is working, not a promise about the outcome.
What should I ask about how denials and old claims are handled?
Ask who works denials, how they are categorized, how quickly a denial is reviewed, what triggers an appeal, how appeal deadlines are tracked, and how you will see denial trends by payer. Ask also how aged A/R is prioritized, and what happens to claims near filing or appeal limits. Ask how root causes feed back into your front-end process, so the same denials do not repeat. The strongest answers describe a workflow with owners and reporting, not only effort. Ask for an example of a recent denial pattern and how it was traced to its cause.
