In this article
- Why medical billing service rates differ so much between companies
- Percentage of collections pricing
- How the percentage model works
- What the percentage model rewards and what it ignores
- Watch points in percentage contracts
- Flat monthly fee pricing
- When a flat fee fits
- Risks of a flat fee
- Per-claim and per-transaction pricing
- How per-claim pricing is calculated
- Where per-claim pricing fits
- Hybrid, tiered, and other pricing structures
- Pricing models side by side
- What should be included in medical billing service rates
- Hidden fees and billing-contract terms that change the real price
- How to compare medical billing quotes with your own numbers
- Which pricing model aligns with your goals
- Contract terms that affect cost beyond the rate
- Red flags in billing company proposals
- What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
- Next steps: get a quote you can actually compare
A quote is only comparable once you know the base the fee is calculated on, the services covered, the extras that are billed separately, and what happens when you leave. Convert every quote into a cost per encounter or cost per dollar collected using your own last 12 months of data. A low rate with a narrow scope can cost more than a higher rate that includes denial work and follow-up.
Why medical billing service rates differ so much between companies
Two practices can ask for quotes on the same day and receive proposals that are impossible to line up. One company quotes a percentage. Another quotes a monthly fee per provider. A third quotes a price per claim plus a setup charge. This is not random. Each structure reflects a different view of who carries the risk of slow payment, how much work a typical claim takes, and which tasks the billing company considers core.
Several practice-side factors move the price no matter which model is chosen:
- Specialty. Anesthesia, radiology, behavioral health, and dental each bill differently. Anesthesia uses time units and modifiers. Behavioral health depends on time-based psychotherapy codes and telehealth rules. Dental uses CDT codes and the ADA claim form, often with a separate dental benefit. More specialty-specific work usually means a higher price or a narrower scope.
- Claim volume and average claim value. A practice with many low-value visits generates more work per dollar collected than one with fewer high-value procedures.
- Payer mix. Medicare, Medicaid, commercial plans, workers compensation, and self-pay each have a different level of denial activity and a different amount of follow-up.
- Current condition of the accounts receivable. A clean ledger is cheap to maintain. A backlog of unworked denials and old balances is a project on top of the monthly work.
- Systems and access. Whether the company works inside your EHR or practice management system, uses its own platform, or needs data moved between systems changes the labor involved.
- Scope. Charge entry only, claims submission only, full revenue cycle management, or billing plus credentialing and prior authorization are all different products.
If you want the broader context for what the work includes before you price it, the step-by-step medical billing process lists every stage from registration to patient collections, and the page on medical billing versus revenue cycle management explains where one service ends and the other begins.
Percentage of collections pricing
This is the most common model. The billing company charges a percentage of the money actually collected on your behalf. If a payment is posted, the company earns its share. If nothing is collected, nothing is owed on that account.
How the percentage model works
The contract defines a rate and a base. The rate is the percentage. The base is the part that people forget to read. Common bases include:
- Payments received from insurance only.
- Payments received from insurance and from patients.
- Payments posted during the contract term, including payments on claims that were submitted before the contract began.
- Payments on claims the company submitted, regardless of when the money arrives, including after termination.
Each of these produces a different invoice from the same practice. The first definition is narrow. The last one can leave you paying a fee on collections that arrive months after you have left. Ask for the exact wording, and ask what happens to payments that arrive after termination on claims that were already in process.
What the percentage model rewards and what it ignores
A percentage aligns the company with higher collections. It also creates a mild pull toward the claims that are easiest to collect. A denied claim for a low balance takes the same effort as a denied claim for a high balance, but pays the company less. A well-run company works both. A poorly run one lets small-dollar denials age out. This is worth testing during evaluation: ask how the company decides which denials are worked and which are written off, and ask whether there is a minimum balance threshold below which claims are not appealed.
The percentage model also means the fee scales with your growth. As revenue rises, so does the invoice, even if the workload per dollar falls. Some contracts address this with tiers, where the percentage steps down at higher collection levels. Others cap the monthly fee. Neither is automatic.
Watch points in percentage contracts
- Collections versus payments received versus net revenue. Make sure refunds, recoupments, and takebacks are handled. If a payer recoups a payment, is the fee on that payment returned?
- Patient payments collected at the front desk. If the base includes money your staff collects at check-in, you are paying a fee on work the billing company did not do.
- Capitation, bundled payments, and non-claim revenue. Decide whether these count toward the base.
- Who holds the money. Payments should go to an account in the practice’s name. If the billing company receives funds first, understand the transfer timing and the bank arrangement.
- Minimum monthly fee. Some percentage contracts include a floor. A floor turns a risk-sharing model into a partly fixed one.
Flat monthly fee pricing
A flat fee sets a fixed monthly price. It may be per practice, per provider, or based on a volume band such as a range of monthly encounters. The invoice does not move with collections.
When a flat fee fits
Flat fees tend to suit practices with high-value, predictable revenue per provider, because a percentage on large collections can exceed the cost of the labor involved. They also suit practices that want a stable monthly budget. Because the fee does not depend on collections, you can predict it, and you can judge the company on outcomes you track yourself.
Risks of a flat fee
- Weaker incentive on difficult claims. The company is paid whether or not the old denial gets worked. Ask for reporting that shows denial follow-up volume and outcomes, not just submission counts.
- Volume bands with overage charges. A fee that is flat up to a certain number of claims may rise above it. Read the band definitions and the overage rate.
- Per-provider definitions. Is a nurse practitioner a provider for pricing purposes? What about a locum or a part-time clinician?
- Scope creep. Flat fees often cover a defined task list. Anything outside it, such as appeals or patient statements, may be priced separately.
Per-claim and per-transaction pricing
In this model the company charges for each claim submitted, or sometimes for each unit of work: a charge entered, a claim filed, a payment posted, a statement sent. It is common for narrow scopes such as claims submission only or electronic remittance posting.
How per-claim pricing is calculated
Three questions determine the real cost:
- What counts as a claim? A corrected claim, a resubmission after rejection, and a secondary claim to a second payer may each be counted again.
- What is excluded? Denial follow-up, appeals, and phone calls to payers are often outside the per-claim price.
- Is there a minimum? A monthly minimum can make a low-volume practice pay more than the per-claim math suggests.
Where per-claim pricing fits
It suits practices that keep most of the revenue cycle in-house and want help with one step, or practices with very uneven volume across months. It is a poor fit if you want someone accountable for the aging report, because a per-claim price pays for submission, not for collection.
Hybrid, tiered, and other pricing structures
Many proposals blend the models above. Common patterns include:
- Base fee plus a smaller percentage. A fixed amount covers core work, and a percentage applies to collections or only to recovered old claims.
- Tiered percentage. The rate declines as monthly collections cross set thresholds.
- Percentage with a cap or floor. The invoice cannot fall below a minimum or rise above a ceiling.
- Project pricing for cleanup. A one-time or contingency price for working a backlog of old unpaid claims, separate from monthly billing.
- Per-provider or per-location fee. A fixed charge for each rendering provider or site.
- Add-on modules. Credentialing, prior authorization, eligibility verification, and coding review priced as separate lines.
Hybrids are not better or worse by default. They are useful when the pieces map to real work. A contingency structure on old claims, for example, is reasonable because that work has uncertain results and a different cost profile from clean current billing. The problem arises when a hybrid hides the effective price behind several small components.
Pricing models side by side
| Model | What you pay for | Where cost can grow | Best match | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of collections | Results on money collected | Broad base definition, fees on payments after termination, fees on front-desk collections | Practices that want cost tied to cash received | Exactly which payments count toward the base? |
| Flat monthly fee | A defined scope and volume | Volume bands, overage, extra providers, out-of-scope tasks | Higher-value practices wanting a stable budget | What is the overage rate and what is excluded? |
| Per claim | Each unit of submission work | Resubmissions, corrected claims, monthly minimums | Narrow scope or uneven volume | Which resubmissions are counted again? |
| Hybrid or tiered | Mix of fixed work and results | Many small components, tier thresholds, add-on modules | Practices with a backlog or varied needs | What is the all-in monthly cost at my last year’s volume? |
What should be included in medical billing service rates
The same word, “billing,” covers very different workloads. Before comparing prices, write down the tasks you expect and check each proposal against the list. A quote that leaves out several rows is not cheaper, it is smaller.
| Task | Why it matters | Often included? |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility and benefits verification | Prevents registration-driven denials before the visit | Varies, sometimes an add-on |
| Charge entry and coding review | Accuracy of CPT or HCPCS, ICD-10-CM, and modifiers | Charge entry often yes, coding review often separate |
| Claim scrubbing and electronic submission | Catches errors before the payer does | Yes |
| Rejection management | Fixes claims that never reach adjudication | Usually yes |
| Payment posting and reconciliation | Matches 835 remittances and deposits to claims | Yes, but check manual EOB handling |
| Denial management and appeals | Where much of the recoverable money sits | Frequently limited or extra |
| Accounts receivable follow-up | Phone and portal work on unpaid claims | Varies by age bucket |
| Patient statements and collections | Patient balances after insurance | Varies, sometimes mailing costs extra |
| Prior authorization | Avoids authorization denials | Usually an add-on |
| Credentialing and enrollment | Required before a provider can bill a payer | Usually separate |
| Reporting | How you verify the work | Standard reports yes, custom reports sometimes extra |
For reference, denial management services and accounts receivable recovery are the two scopes most often left thin in low quotes, and they are where unpaid revenue tends to accumulate.
Hidden fees and billing-contract terms that change the real price
Hidden is not always the right word. Most of these items are in the contract. They are simply not in the sales conversation. Read the agreement for each of the following.
- Setup, onboarding, or implementation fee. One-time charges to load payers, fee schedules, and provider data.
- Clearinghouse and transaction fees. Some companies pass through per-claim clearinghouse costs or charge for 835 and 277 transactions.
- Software or platform fee. A monthly charge for access to the company’s system or for connecting to your EHR.
- Statement and mailing charges. Paper patient statements may be billed per page or per mailing.
- Appeals and reprocessing fees. A separate charge for appeals, or a percentage on appealed amounts.
- Old claim and cleanup fees. A different rate for work on claims dated before the start date.
- Credentialing and revalidation charges. Per application or per payer.
- Minimum monthly fee. A floor that applies in slow months.
- Annual rate increases. An automatic escalator, or a right to change rates with notice.
- Termination and data export fees. Charges for transferring data, producing reports, or ending the agreement early.
- Auto-renewal and notice periods. A long notice window can lock you in for another term.
- Fees after termination. A tail period during which the company still collects its percentage on claims it submitted.
Request a one-page list of every charge the company bills in a normal month, plus every one-time and occasional charge. If a company cannot produce it, the invoice will probably surprise you later. The same discipline applies to the questions you ask during evaluation, which cover contract terms in more depth.
How to compare medical billing quotes with your own numbers
The most reliable method is to translate every quote into the same two measures: cost per encounter and cost as a share of collections. You need three pieces of your own data for the last 12 months: total payments collected, number of encounters or claims, and the number of providers. Your practice management system and your bank deposits can supply these.
- List the scope in each quote using the task table above. Mark each row as included, extra, or absent.
- Add every recurring and one-time fee from the all-in sheet.
- Apply the quote to your last year’s volume. Use actual collections for percentage quotes, actual claim counts for per-claim quotes, and actual provider counts for per-provider quotes.
- Add the cost of tasks you would still do yourself that the other quote includes. A cheaper quote that leaves denial work with your staff is not cheaper if you still pay that staff.
- Stress test with a bad month and a good month. See how each structure behaves when collections fall or volume spikes.
- Project one year of growth. If you plan to add a provider, calculate each quote again.
Hypothetical example. The figures below are round illustrations, not market data. A practice collected $1,000,000 last year across 10,000 claims with 4 providers. Quote A is a percentage of collections. Quote B is a flat monthly fee per provider with denial work excluded. Quote C is a per-claim fee with appeals billed separately.
| Step | Quote A: percentage | Quote B: flat per provider | Quote C: per claim |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost driver | $1,000,000 collections | 4 providers | 10,000 claims |
| Recurring fee for the year | Rate times $1,000,000 | Monthly fee times 4 times 12 | Fee times 10,000 |
| Add one-time and pass-through charges | Setup, statements | Setup, clearinghouse | Setup, resubmission counts |
| Work left with practice staff | Little | Denials and appeals | Denials, appeals, follow-up |
| Effective cost per claim | Total divided by 10,000 | Total plus staff time divided by 10,000 | Total plus staff time divided by 10,000 |
Fill in the real rates from each proposal. Then add one more line: the share of last year’s denials that the quote commits the company to work. The result often reverses the order that the headline numbers suggested. A quote that looks cheapest on recurring cost can come out highest once denial work is priced in, and a percentage that looks high can come out reasonable once you see it covers follow-up that the other two leave to you.
Which pricing model aligns with your goals
No structure removes the need to verify the work. Each one rewards a different behavior, and you should choose the one whose weak spot you can monitor.
| If your main concern is | Lean toward | Then monitor |
|---|---|---|
| Paying only when money arrives | Percentage of collections | Denial and aging reports, small balances being skipped |
| Predictable monthly cost | Flat fee with clear volume bands | Denial follow-up activity and overage terms |
| Help on one step only | Per-claim or per-task pricing | Definition of a billable claim, resubmissions |
| A backlog of old unpaid claims | Hybrid with separate cleanup terms | Cutoff dates, recovery reporting by age |
| Fast growth or new locations | Percentage or tiered structure | Rate tiers, per-location charges |
Whatever you choose, the numbers that tell you whether the arrangement works are the same: clean claim rate, denial rate by cause, days in A/R, and percentage of A/R over 90 days. The article on clean claim rate and days in A/R explains how each is calculated so that you can write the definitions into the contract.
Contract terms that affect cost beyond the rate
Some of the most expensive clauses are not about fees at all.
- Term and renewal. Length of the initial term, automatic renewal, and the notice needed to leave.
- Termination for cause and for convenience. Whether you can leave if reports are late or accounts go unworked, and what it costs.
- Data ownership and export. The practice should own its billing data and receive it in a usable format when the agreement ends.
- Tail fees. Fees on collections after termination. See the dedicated discussion of what happens to old unpaid claims when switching billing companies.
- Business associate agreement. A signed BAA is expected before the company touches protected health information. HHS publishes sample provisions that cover permitted uses, safeguards, breach reporting, subcontractors, and return or destruction of information at termination.
- Performance commitments. Reporting deadlines, response times to your questions, and the remedy if they are missed. Be wary of any contract that promises a specific collection result, since payer decisions are outside any vendor’s control.
- Liability and indemnity. Who pays if a billing error leads to an overpayment, recoupment, or compliance finding. Billing errors that lead to overpayments remain a practice obligation to correct, so the contract should say how the company assists.
Red flags in billing company proposals
- A single number with no written scope.
- A promise of a collection result or a specific denial rate.
- A refusal to share a sample report or a sample invoice.
- Payments routed to an account the practice does not control.
- A fee base that includes money the company did not work.
- No clear answer about who owns the data and how it is returned.
- Pressure to sign before a review of your actual claim history.
- No mention of a BAA, or reluctance to sign yours.
What Mednex handles and what the practice handles
Under a medical billing engagement, Mednex works the claim cycle: eligibility checks, charge review, claim submission, payment posting, denial follow-up, and accounts receivable work, with revenue cycle management as a broader option. The practice supplies accurate encounter documentation, charge data, provider information, and access to its systems or exports. The practice also keeps the final say on clinical documentation and on billing policy decisions such as write-offs and payment plans.
Mednex does not set payer policies, decide reimbursement, or promise outcomes. The pricing structure for an engagement is quoted after Mednex reviews specialty, volume, payer mix, and scope, and is confirmed in writing before work begins.
Next steps: get a quote you can actually compare
Before you request any quote, pull your last 12 months of collections, claim counts, provider list, and an A/R aging report by payer. With those in hand, every proposal can be measured on the same basis. If you would like a neutral look at where money is being lost today, which also tells you how much work a billing partner would face, the free medical billing audit reviews a sample of claims, denial reasons, A/R aging, and charge capture gaps and returns a written summary. You can also compare in-house and outsourced options in the guide on outsourcing medical billing versus keeping it in-house, or browse more guides in the Mednex blog.
This guide is educational. It is not legal, coding, compliance or clinical advice. Rules differ by payer, plan, state and contract, so confirm against the payer's current policy before acting.
Frequently asked questions
How do medical billing companies charge?
Most use one of four structures: a percentage of collections, a flat monthly fee, a fee per claim, or a hybrid such as a base fee plus a smaller percentage. Percentage pricing ties the fee to what is collected, flat fees give predictable cost, and per-claim fees scale with volume. Each has a different base, meaning what the fee applies to, and different exclusions. Mednex does not publish prices here, and any quote should be confirmed in writing. Ask what the fee is calculated on, which services are included, and what happens to payments on claims submitted before the contract started.
Is percentage of collections or flat fee better for a practice?
Neither is better in every case. A percentage aligns the company with higher collections and scales with growth, but it can cost more as revenue per provider rises. A flat fee is predictable and can suit high-value, steady revenue, but it gives less built-in incentive tied to collections and may not cover extra work. Compare each quote by converting it to a cost per encounter or cost per dollar collected using your own last 12 months of data. Then check what is included, because a lower rate with narrower scope can cost more overall. Revisit the choice if your volume, specialty mix, or payer mix changes.
What should be included in a medical billing quote?
A complete quote states the fee base, the rate, and the services covered: eligibility checks, charge review, claim submission, payment posting, denial work, A/R follow-up, patient statements, and reporting. It should also state what is excluded or charged separately, such as credentialing, prior authorization, coding review, old A/R recovery, clearinghouse fees, and software or EHR costs. Ask for the contract term, notice period, tail provisions, minimums, and how fees are handled on refunds or reversed payments. Get everything in writing before you compare quotes. Request the same written scope from every company so the quotes line up, and note any service that shows as optional.
What are hidden fees in medical billing?
Hidden fees are costs not clear in the headline rate. Examples include setup or onboarding charges, minimum monthly fees, separate fees for statements or clearinghouse use, charges for appeals or old A/R, fees on payments the company did not generate, and termination or data-export fees. A percentage may also apply to patient copays, refunds, or recoupments in ways you did not expect. Ask for a complete fee schedule, and ask what the percentage is applied to. Read the termination and tail clauses before you sign, since they affect your cost of leaving. Keep a copy of every fee schedule and amendment, because later disputes usually turn on what was agreed in writing.
Does a billing company charge a percentage on old unpaid claims?
It depends on the contract. Some companies apply the normal rate to all payments received after the start date, even on claims billed before they joined. Others set a separate rate for recovery of old claims, a flat project fee, or a tiered rate. Decide beforehand whether payments on legacy claims are in or out of the base, and how the company tracks them. The article on old unpaid claims when switching billing companies explains how to set cutoff dates and reconcile reports so the answer is clear in writing.
How do I compare two medical billing quotes?
Put both quotes on the same basis. Convert each to a total cost for a sample year using your own collections and claim counts, then divide by encounters or by dollars collected. Next compare scope line by line, since one quote may include denial work and credentialing while another does not. Then compare the terms: contract length, notice period, minimums, data ownership, reporting, and tail. Finally compare transparency, such as whether reports show claim-level detail. A quote that looks lower on rate may cost more once exclusions are added. Weight your own data heavily here: last year's claim count and collections turn a vague quote into a figure you can check.
Are there setup fees or long-term contracts?
Some companies charge setup or onboarding fees and some do not, and contract lengths range from month to month to multi-year terms, so ask directly. Check the cancellation clause, the notice period, any early termination fee, and what you receive at the end: your claim data, remittances, and A/R reports in a usable format. A shorter term with a clear exit often matters more than a lower rate. Do not assume any term from another company applies, and have the contract reviewed by someone who handles your practice agreements. Ask for the full agreement before any call about price, so the terms are not a surprise after you have decided.
Does a lower billing fee mean lower total cost?
Not necessarily. A low fee can hide narrow scope, extra charges, slower follow-up, or weaker reporting, any of which can cost more than the savings. The total effect also depends on how many claims are denied or left unworked, which no fee percentage shows on its own. Compare the full package: fee base, included services, charges outside scope, contract terms, and reporting. Judge results using your own metrics, such as days in A/R and denial rate, defined the same way before and after. No company can guarantee a specific collection result. Also ask how you will see results, because a fee is only fair if you can verify what it buys.
Can Mednex quote a price for my practice?
Mednex handles pricing through a conversation about your scope, claim volume, specialties, and payers, so a useful quote starts with your data. The free billing audit is a separate first step: it reviews a sample and gives a written findings summary and a walkthrough, with no obligation. It is not a substitute for a quote, and it does not promise any result. Pricing model and terms should be confirmed in writing, and you should compare them with other offers using the steps in this guide. Bring recent report exports, such as an A/R aging and a denial report, so the discussion starts from your own numbers.
